Validation of leak test models for pharmaceutical isolators

  • Authors

    • Shih-Cheng Hu
    • Angus Shiue National Taipei University of Technology
    • Yu-Min Hsu
    • Yi-Sung Ke
    2015-04-05
    https://doi.org/10.14419/ijet.v4i2.4432
  • Isolator, Leak Test, Particle Count Method, SF6 Tracer Gas Method, Pressure Decay Test.
  • In this study, we performed three leak tests on a side-recirculated air isolator: a particle-count test, performed at a variety of positive and negative pressures; the SF6 trace gas method, performed at a variety of airflow velocities; and a pressure decay method, performed at a variety of initial pressures. From the particle-count test, we measured particle leak ratios of 30–34% for pressures of −18 to −25 Pa. In contrast, using the SF6 tracer gas method. we measured leak ratios of 7.8%, 5.9%, and 3.8% for airflow velocities of 0.61, 0.51, and 0.41 m/s, respectively. The particle-count test detected leaks quickly and easily, but its leak ratio was overly high because it included particles from outside of the chamber as well as from the filter. Although the SF6 tracer gas method took more time, it was more sensitive and accurate. The leak quantity would be affected by air velocity and the pressure. Leak concentration acted as sterilization phase of isolator that would result in concentration distributed nonhomogeneous phenomena; concentration distributed from outside of the chamber can be acted as a leakage diffusion situation of contaminants leak. Using the pressure decay method to compare downward airflow through a raised-floor and side-wall return air isolators, the fall time, leak quantity, and leak area of the downward airflow through a raised-floor isolator was five times greater, four times les, and 4.5 times less than that of the side-wall return-air isolator, respectively. According to idea gas law, keeping the temperature and pressure of the chamber constant will effectively reduce the leak quantity.

  • References

    1. [1] Food and Drug Administration, Guidance for Industry, “Sterile Drug Products Produced by Aseptic Processing,†September (2004), www.fda.gov.

      [2] United States Pharmacopeia, “Sterility Testing – Validation of Isolator Systems,†USP XXIII Informational Chapter 1208, Pharmacopeial Forum 23 No. 6, (1997).

      [3] United States Pharmacopeia 27 and National Formulary 22, “Pharmaceutical Compounding – Sterile Preparations,†Chapter 797, 319 - 336.

      [4] PIC/S Recommendation “Isolators Used for Aseptic Processing and Sterility Testing,†presented at the Pharmaceutical Inspection Convention, June (2002).

      [5] European Commision, Directive 2003/94/EC, annex 1, “Manufacture of sterile Medicinal Products,†May (2003), Revision (2008).

      [6] International Standard, ISO 14644-7, “Cleanrooms and Associated Controlled Environments†Part 7 Separative Devices (Clean Air Hoods, Gloveboxes, Isolators and Mini Environments) (2004).

      [7] International Society for Pharmaceutical Engineering, ISPE, Annual Barrier Isolation Conference, www.ispe.org.

      [8] Parenteral Drug Association, PDA, Technical Report No. 34 “Design and Validation of Isolator Systems for the Manufacturing and Testing of Health Care Products,†September/October (2001), www.pda.org.

      [9] Arbeitsgemeinschaft fur Pharmazeutische Verfahrenstechnik APV, “From Cleanroom to Isolator Technology,†APV Course, Basel/Switzerland, May (2008).

      [10] Verein Deutscher Ingenieure VDI, VDI 2083, Blatt 16, Barrieresysteme, under work; http://www.vdi.de.

      [11] Arvind Asthana, A., “Isolator: Case study of Issues Involvedâ€, Pharma Times Vol. 43, No. 10 (2011) 31.

      [12] ISO 10648-2:1994, “Containment enclosures -- Part 2: Classification according to leak tightness and associated checking methodsâ€.

      [13] Coles, T., “Leak rate measurement for pharmaceutical isolators: Practical guidance for operators and test engineersâ€, Clean Air and Containment Review, Vol. 11 (2012) 8-12 (2012).

      [14] International Standard, ISO 14644-1, “Cleanrooms and Associated Controlled Environments†Part 1 Classification of air cleanliness, (1999).

      [15] Lagus, P.L., “Control Room In leakage Measurements using Tracer Gas Techniquesâ€, Vent (2006). http://dx.doi.org/10.3320/1.2759030.

      [16] Midcalf, B., W. M. Phillips, J. S. Neiger, and T. J. Coles, “Pharmaceutical Isolators. Pharmaceutical Pressâ€, (2004).

  • Downloads

  • How to Cite

    Hu, S.-C., Shiue, A., Hsu, Y.-M., & Ke, Y.-S. (2015). Validation of leak test models for pharmaceutical isolators. International Journal of Engineering & Technology, 4(2), 311-319. https://doi.org/10.14419/ijet.v4i2.4432