Coverage Analysis of Indonesia Sustainability Assessment Tools: Similarity in Dimension and Assessment Results

  • Abstract
  • Keywords
  • References
  • PDF
  • Abstract

    The number of sustainability assessment tools in Indonesia is growing rapidly, concerns are raised on whether the assessment results of different tools present similar and valid conclusion about the sustainability performance in manufacturing industry. In this paper, we analyze dimensions of sustainability assessment tools and compare the structures of sustainability tools in Indonesia. Using a coverage analysis to demonstrate the similarity and differences between two sustainability assessments in Indonesia (PROPER and Industri Hijau) we then compare the results of both and analyze it. This study shows that two sustainability assessment tools in Indonesia which are PROPER and Industri Hijau have high variations in their structures, indicators, criteria, and sub-themes despite their similar dimension and purpose.  Consequently,  these sustainability assessment  tools  show  differences  in  assessment results  and  conclusions  on  the  sustainability  performance  of firms. Future research may propose a new integrated sustainability assessment tool so there will be only one sustainability assessment tool in Indonesia.



  • Keywords

    Sustainability, PROPER, Industri Hijau, Coverage Analysis

  • References

      [1] P. Found, et al, “A theoretical framework for economic sustainability of manufacturing industry,” paper presented at the European Operations Management Association (EUROMA) Conference, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow. 2006.

      [2] S. C. Feng, and C. B. Joung, “A measurement infrastructure for sustainable manufacturing,” International Journal Sustainable Manufacturing. Vol. 2, 2011.

      [3] Visser WAM-T, “Sustainability reporting in South Africa,” Corporate Environmental Strategy. Vol. 9, pp. 79-85, 2002

      [4] T. Sterner, and J. Coria, “Policy Instrument for Environmental and Natural Resources Management,” RFF Press. London. 2012.

      [5] P. Bansal, “Evolving sustainably: a longitudinal study of corporate sustainable development,” Strategic Management Journal, vol. 26, pp. 197–218, 2005

      [6] E. M. De Olde, E. A. M. Bokkers, I. J. M. De Boer, “The choice of the sustainability assessment tool matters: differences in thematic scope and assessment result,” Ecological Economics, vol. 136, pp. 77-85, 2017.

      [7] R. Lozano, “Sustainability inter-linkages in reporting vindicated: a study of European companies,” Journal of Cleaner Production, vol 51, pp. 57-65, 2013.

      [8] JM. Prado-Lorenzo, I. Gallego-Alvarez, I.M. Garcia-Sanchez, “Stakeholder engagement and corporate social responsibility reporting: the ownership structure effect”. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management. Wiley InterScience. Vol 16. pp 94-107. 2009.

      [9] V. Gasso, F. W. Oudshoorn, E. De Olde, C. A. G. Sorensen, “Generic sustainability assessment themes and the role of context: the case of Danish maize for german biogas,” Ecological Indicators, vol. 49, pp. 143-153, 2014.

      [10] C. Bockstaller, et al, “Comparison of methods to assess the sustainability of agricultural systems,” A review, Agronomy Sustainaibility Development, vol. 29, pp. 223–235, 2009.

      [11] M. B. Galan, D. Peschard, H. Boizard,. “ISO 14 001 at the farm level: analysis of five methods for evaluating the environmental impact of agricultural practices,” Journal of Environmental Management, vol. 82, pp. 341-352, 2007.

      [12] C. B. Joung, J. Carrell, P. Sarkar, S. C. Feng, “Categorization of indicators for sustainability manufacturing,” Ecological Indicators, vol.24, pp. 148-157, 2012.

      [13] WCED (World Commision on Environment and Development), “Our common future,” Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1987.

      [14] D. Mebratu, “Sustainability and sustainability development: historical and conceptual review,” Environmental Impact Assessment Review, vol.18, pp. 493-520. November 1998.

      [15] R. Berkenmeyer, D. Holt, L. Preuss and S. Tsang, “What Happened to the ‘Development’ in Sustainable Development? Business Guidelines Two Decades after Brundtland,” Sustainable Development, Wiley Online Library, 2011.

      [16] E. D. Ozdemir, M. Hardtlein, T. Jenssen, D. Zech, L. Eltrop, “A confusion of tongues or the art of aggregating indicators e reflections on four projective methodologies on sustainability assessment,” Renewable and Sustainability Energy Reviews, vol. 15, pp. 2385-2396, 2011.

      [17] C. Labuschagne, A. C. Brent, R. P. G.Van Erck, “Assesing the sustainability performances of industries,” Journal of Cleaner Production, vol. 13, pp. 373-385. 2005.

      [18] PROPER Publications, Ministry of Environment, Indonesia, 2015.

      [19] C. Schader, J. Grenz, M. S. Meier, M. Stolze, “Scope and precision of sustainability assessment approaches to food systems,” Ecology and Society, vol. 19, pp. 42. 2014.

      [20] S. Sala, B. Ciuffo, P. Nijkamp, “A systemic framework for sustainability assessment,” Ecological Economics, vol. 119, pp. 314-325. 2015

      [21] E. M. De Olde, F. W. Oudshoorn, C. A. G. Sorensen, E. A. M. Bokkers, I. J. M. De Boer, “Assessing sustainability at farm-level: Lesson learned from a comparison of tools in practice,” Ecological Indicators, vol. 66, pp. 391-404. 2016.

      [22] R. Y. J. Siew, “A review of corporate sustainability reporting tools (SRTs),” Journal of Environmental Management, vol. 164, pp. 180-195. 2015.

      [23] C. Searcy, S. Karapetrovic, D. McCartney, “Designing sustainable development indicators: analysis for a case utiity,” Measuring Business Excellence, vol. 9, pp. 33-41. 2005

      [24] T. Galpin, J. L. Whittington, G. Bell, “Is your sustainability strategy sustainable? Creating a culture of sustainability,” Corporate Governance, vol. 15, pp. 1-17. 2015.

      [25] S. I. Hallstedt, “Sustainability criteria and sustainability compliance index for decision support in product development,” Journal of Cleaner Production, vol. 140, pp. 251-266, 2017.

      [26] A.Gasparatos, “Embedded value systems in sustainability assessment tools and their implication,” Journal of Environmental Management, vol. 91, pp. 1613-1622. 2010.

      [27] Thomas, M. Francis, “Identifying the characteristic for achieving sustainable manufacturing companies,” Journal of Manufacturing Technology Management, vol. 23, pp. 426-440, 2012.

      [28] K. Valkokari, et al, “Road-mapping the business potential of sustainability within the European manufacturing industry,”Foresight, vol. 16, pp. 360-384, 2014

      [29] IEA, “Worldwide Trends in Energy Use and Efficiency: Key Insights from IEA Indicator Analysis,” International Energy Agency (IEA), Paris, 2008.

      [30] P. Soderbaum, “Making actors, paradigms and ideologies visible in governance of sustainability”, Sustainable Development, vol. 17, pp.70-81, 2009.




Article ID: 13911
DOI: 10.14419/ijet.v7i2.34.13911

Copyright © 2012-2015 Science Publishing Corporation Inc. All rights reserved.