The ambivalence of santiago a psychoanalytic study


  • T S. Sujatha



Id, ego, Superego, Oedipus complex, Sublimation, Ambivalence, Life Principle, Death Drive.


Santiago, the protagonist of the American novelist, Ernest Hemingway’s novella, The Old Man and the Sea is certainly a sphinx amongst complex characters in fictional literature. A true understanding of this very puzzling character is beyond the scope of the conventional study methods of critical reading, critical analysis, critical appreciation etc. Only a psychoanalytic approach offers us some prospect of being able to understand the dichotomy between the psyche and the persona of Santiago. However, it needs to be emphasized here that the psychoanalytic approach is neither superior nor inferior to the other approaches. It is only a very different kind of approach that promises new possibilities. Its application is justified when our subject of study happens to be a complex character like Santiago. We also need to remain alert and wary of the fact that a pseudo-psychoanalytic study can easily lead to absurd understandings. This paper reports a study of Santiago’s character based specifically on Freudian Classical Psychoanalytic Theory of Personality. At the same time, however, it does not altogether disregard or discount Jungian or Lacanian psychoanalyses. The objective of this paper is to explain in psychoanalytic terms how Santiago is saved from becoming dangerously paranoid, schizoid and maniacal.




[1] Blesser CE, Literary Criticism. An Introduction to Theory and Practice United States of America: Houghton College, (1998).

[2] Ernest H, Scribner, the Old Man and the Sea. Novella New York, (1952)

[3] Freud S, the Ego and the Id (The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud). N.Y., New York. W.W. Norton and Company, (1962).

[4] Freud A, the Ego and the Mechanisms of Defence, Karnac Books Ltd, 118 Finchley Road London NW3 5HT, (1936).

[5] Stay P & Lapsley DK, Ego and Superego. University of Notre Dame: Elsevier, (2011).

Internet references

[1] Faulkner J, Freud's Concept of the Death Drive and Its Relation to the Superego, (2005).

[2] McLeod SA & Carl J,, (2014).

[3] McLeod SA & Superego E, (2016)

[4] Seltzer LF, https://www.psychologytodaycom/experts/leon-f-seltzer-phd, (2014).

[5] Mandy GG, A Lacanian Analysis of Hemingway’s Search for Spirituality., (2013).

[6] Saeed Momtazi MD, Destroyed but not defeated: Hemingway’s The Old Man and the Sea: A psychotherapeutic, Story,, (2003).

[7] Alenca J, Humor after Eclipse. 1042660088, (2013).

[8] Clinton SB, Hemingway’s Tragic Vision of Man, https://www., (1960).

[9] Nemotolla M & Lingaraj G, The concept of Thanatos in Hemingway’s Novels,, (2007).

[10] Poetry Foundation (2013) Ernest M. Hemingway (1899-1961), (

[11] Mokaya N Freudian & Lacanian. Psychoanalyses: A Comparison and Contrast, LACAN IAN_PSYCHOANALYSES_A_CO, (2017).

View Full Article: